top of page

We Will Dance Again

Oct 9
3 min read

By Rabbi Shlomo Farhi


At the conclusion of Parashat Beresheet, Adam HaRishon is expelled from Gan Eden. The Torah tells us that Hashem places the Keruvim and the flaming sword “mikedem l’Gan Eden”—to the east of the Garden of Eden—to guard the path to the Tree of Life.

Later, after Kayin murders his brother Hevel, the Torah tells us that he settles in Eretz Nod, “kidmat Eden”—east of Eden.


Why does the Torah emphasize this direction? Why is it important for us to know that both Adam and Kayin find themselves east of Gan Eden?

Perhaps the answer lies in the word kedem itself.


Kedem means “east,” but it also means “before,” as in the word kodem. Perhaps the Torah is teaching us something extraordinary: even after Adam loses Gan Eden, even after Kayin commits an unimaginable sin, Hashem places them in a position that points toward what came before.


They have lost something precious, but they have not lost the possibility of returning.

This gives us a beautiful new understanding of the blessing we give a bride and groom beneath the chuppah: “K’samechacha yetzircha b’Gan Eden mikedem.” We ask Hashem to bring them the joy that existed in Gan Eden of old.

But perhaps we are asking for something even greater. We are blessing them that even when life takes them outside their Gan Eden, they should always have a pathway back.

Every person experiences moments when life feels like Gan Eden: a beautiful marriage, a happy family, good health, financial stability, peace of mind. Everything seems to fall naturally into place.


And then something changes.


A relationship becomes strained. Illness arrives. A family experiences conflict. A person loses something they thought would always be there.

Suddenly, they find themselves standing outside the gates of their own Gan Eden, looking back at a life they believe they can never recover.

But just because we cannot return to the circumstances we once had does not mean we cannot rediscover the joy we once felt.


The second time, however, may require a fight.

A marriage that was once effortlessly peaceful may now require patience, forgiveness, and tremendous work. But perhaps the shalom bayit that emerges from that struggle is even stronger than the peace that existed before. The first was never tested. The second was earned.


The same is true of happiness, faith, and our relationship with Hashem. What once came naturally may now demand courage and determination. That does not make it less beautiful. In many ways, it makes it more meaningful.

This idea brings to mind the extraordinary words adopted by survivors of the October 7 massacre at the Nova music festival:


“We will dance again.”

Not simply, “We will dance.” We will dance again.


Those words express a remarkable belief in the human spirit. They declare that even after unimaginable darkness, joy is not necessarily lost forever. Life may never look the same, but the capacity to experience happiness, connection, and meaning can still exist.

Of course, there are tragedies for which we have no answers. There are losses that cannot be undone and pain that no words can erase. We cannot pretend otherwise.

But there is a profound difference between acknowledging that life will never be the same and believing that life can never again contain beauty.


The Gemara tells us that Rabbi Akiva once survived a terrible storm at sea. When asked how he managed to endure the crashing waves, he answered, “Al kol gal vagal nina’ati et roshi”—with every wave, I bowed my head.


Rather than fighting each wave head-on, he lowered himself and allowed it to pass.

There is a beautiful additional insight here. The Hebrew word gal, meaning “wave,” echoes the word gilui, “revelation.” And the image of bowing one’s head can also suggest a nod of understanding.


Perhaps we can hear another lesson in Rabbi Akiva’s words: every wave in life may carry an opportunity to recognize something deeper. Amid difficulty, we can seek the humility, faith, and determination to continue forward.


That is the message we can find in mikedem.


The path toward Gan Eden was guarded by angels and a flaming sword. Finding our way toward joy again may also feel daunting. Yet Hashem planted within humanity the extraordinary ability to rebuild and rediscover.


We may not return by the same pat

h. We may carry scars we never had before. The world around us may be entirely different.


But the Gan Eden we thought was behind us may still be something we can move toward.

And with Hashem’s help, we will dance again.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page